The French in Mali are being counterproductive

/10/jonathanpower2.jpg”>

Are we in Mali being caught up in the fallout from the reaction to the reaction of 9/11? It very much looks like it. First, the destruction of the World Trade Center. Then the first reaction – the bombing of the Taliban in Afghanistan, the subsequent war and the loose talk about “the clash of civilizations”.

Then the second reaction – anger and hostility from one end of the Islamic world to the other. Although the dust has now settled on that, thanks not least to Al Qaeda overstepping its mark and killing Muslims, there is in some parts a residual hostility- a sea in which the few remaining Islamic militants can swim.

But these militants by and large have not done well. Since 9/11 there has not been one successful attack on the USA. In Europe in what few attacks there have been the perpetuators have not been part of Al Qaeda, merely sympathisers and imitators. Most Muslims have been revolted by what is has been and is being done in their name – in Indonesia, Malaysia, The Gulf states, Turkey, Jordan, and the 160 million in India. Not one of these countries has produced one militant with a foreign agenda.

There are bits and pieces of Al Qaeda here and there – members or sympathisers. They are scattered in small groups – in Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia, northern Nigeria and Mali.

It’s doubtful if the militants could grow larger, with one big “unless” – unless the US or Israel bombs Iran. That could trigger a resurgence of Al Qaeda. Iran, which has shunned the organization, could welcome its support, and parts of the Muslim world would be back to feeling hostile to the US.

Military intervention rarely works. I can only think of two recent cases when it did – when the British went into Sierra Leone and put the country back on its feet after it had been raped by Charles Taylor, recently condemned in the International War Crimes Court, and when the French went into the Ivory Coast to restore democracy. In both cases they confronted ragtag forces with only a domestic agenda.

Did intervention work in Vietnam? The Americans believed it was a domino – if it fell to communism so would all the countries around. But there was no North Vietnamese-Soviet-Chinese imperialistic axis. Getting rid of the Americans and conquering South Vietnam was the limited purpose. The US was forced to retreat. Now the same is happening in Afghanistan.

The only interventions that regularly work are UN ones. But the blue helmets usually only go in when a peace has been negotiated and they are needed to hold the ring and to help pacify the country.

In Libya the West should have left the Arab Spring uprising to itself. By bombing and encouraging the militants in their violence they made a post-Gadhafi transition more difficult. It destabilized the country and pushed the militants who Gadhafi kept under control into the Sahara, in particular into Mali. The militants should have been encouraged by the West to aim for a non-violent take-over as they were in Tunisia and Egypt, not fed with arms and supported by aerial bombardment.

The French have over-reacted in Mali. The Tuaregs, with their long-time call for autonomy or independence, have now split from the Islamic militants. The militants for their part only captured three small backwater towns using two columns of around 150 vehicles with around 600 men. What could they have done if they had advanced into the capital, Bamako, with its population of 1.8 million?

They would have been quickly set upon by residents, overwhelmed, disarmed and swallowed up. The authority of the Malian government could have been secured by the West African troops now deployed in Mali. They could keep the peace UN-style.

President Barack Obama said in in his inaugural address “A decade of war is now ending”. And the US does not need a surrogate, France. Nor does it need France to stir the world-wide Islamic pot.

It is not too late for the French to change their policy. Going after all the “friends of Al Qaeda” deep into the desert is mistaken. (They are no more than that, with their very loose connections with the original Al Qaeda.) The French should stop where they are with the relief of Timbuktu and two other small desert towns. (Since they are now on the spot its precious manuscripts and other historic artifacts need to be saved and secured- a small contingent can do that.)

The large majority of the French forces should pack their bags. Some can stay to help re-train the Malian army and police forces, but that should be it. The Malian government, for its part, should consider the reasonable demand of the Tuaregs for autonomy.

The French should look at the lessons of history. If they stay there is a good chance they will feed the growth of the militants not defeat them. Intervention does not work.

Copyright: Jonathan Power 2013

jonatpower@aol.com

Foreign affairs columnist, film-maker and author

Related Posts

LONDON – So far so good, at least on the wider level. While internally Iraq seems on the edge of chaos, the much heralded clash of civilizations between the Muslim and Judaeo-Christian worlds has yet to become apparent. We have anger and despair aplenty in the Arab and Muslim worlds. But very little rushing to the standard and there was no great pilgrimage of warriors to join the fight, as happened when the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan twenty years ago, and then, having driven the Red Army out, were left to ferment in that mountainous redoubt. With the armaments supplied by the CIA the mujahidin were transformed into Al Qaeda that became, for a relatively brief moment as these things go, ‘the greatest threat to the homeland that America has ever known.’ Nevertheless a ‘Cold War’ between much of the Muslim world and the West is certainly in full swing. Winston...
Eastern Aleppo. al-Nusra occupation. Photo © Jan Oberg 2016 TFF is also your go-to source for understanding the Syria catastrophe in the making from now on. Jan Oberg December 9, 2024 Introduction: The colonialist mentality Few things should surprise us anymore regarding the un-principled nature of the contemporary Western world. One day it sees a genocide and keeps supporting its ongoing barbarism. The next day – actually December 8 in the early morning – it fully supports terrorism, which, allegedly, it has been fighting since September 11, 2001. NATO countries such as the US and Turkey are the main supporters of the terrorist movements that have now occupied the cultured country, Syria, home to 25 million extremely mixed people. As far as I have looked into it, no Western leader has pointed out that taking over an entire country and sending its leadership fleeing is a violation of international law;...
The collective cynicism is ugly. The innocent Syrian people are now doomed. The author hopes that his predictions shall soon be proven wrong… Jan Oberg December 8, 2024 This article was published at 02:36, about 4 hours before the HTS terrorists occupied Damascus. • Lebanon-based al-Mayadeen reports tonight, December 8, 2024, that Russia, Iran, Turkey call for immediate end to hostilities in Syria. My cynical interpretation of this – beyond pathetic – “call” is the following: Turkey knew and did/does all it can – again – to destroy Syria. Russia and Iran were surprised or act surprised; they can do nothing given their own malaise. Or their “intelligence” services failed miserably? Their common statement is devoid of constructive steps in this uniquely urgent situation. It does not even mention the Syrian government or its President. They “call for” terrorists who are approaching the outskirts of Damascus and have declared long...

Recent Articles

A Message from Jan Oberg November 6, 2026 Over the past fifty years, I have devoted roughly 175,000 hours to research and public education for a more peaceful world: thinking, researching, writing, organising, publishing, debating, maintaining websites, corresponding, reaching out, leading a foundation, work in conflict and war zones, professorships, teaching courses and giving public lectures and doing media work. In short, ten hours a day, seven days a week, for half a century. The focus was on international political peace – analysing and trying to stop wars, address underlying conflicts and making alternative peace plans – at the desk and on the ground. Important as that has been and remains, it is only one kind of peace and it is now in a tragic militarist state compared with what it could have been.  Lately, however, I have found myself thinking about a concept from economics as well as everyday...
Photo above: Carl Fredrik Reuterswärd’s Non-Violence outside UN Headquarters in New York. Kirill Levin, CC BY-NC-SA 2. Jan Oberg November 3, 2026 I am happy to be published in Horizons which is produced by the Center for International Relations and Sustainable Development, CIRSD, in Belgrade. My contribution brings out a radical re-thinking of what concepts such as defence, security, deterrence – and peace – may mean if we want to create a more peaceful world. It also summarises a few things I have been working with the last few decades. Please read it here Og her er den på dansk, takket være Johnny Baltzersens lynhurtige oversættelse
UNITE-tillid, DREAM-velstand og andre konstruktive komponenter Normally we publish articles in English here. But this is a translation of a very important TFF document that should reach as many as possible in Denmark since this country’s government has been one of the most hardline in Europe and, up till now at least, has refused to use diplomacy and, instead, spent tremendous sums on arming Ukraine with the express goal of defeating Russia. Thus this – unique – article is in Danish. Vi er Johnny Baltzersen og hans Fælles Sikkerhed – Fælles Fremtid på Substack overmåde taknemmelige for at have oversat og publiceret TFF’s 2025-portfølje for fredsidéer med henblik på Ukraines fremtid. Vi håber den nu kan nå mange flere danskere – som også vil sprede den og skabe debat – nu den danske regerings og folketingspartiernes politik på dette område siden 2022 står nu – forudsigeligt – ved vejs ende....

TFF on Substack

Discover and subscribe to more peace materials on TFF Substack

Most Popular

A Message from Jan Oberg November 6, 2026 Over the past fifty years, I have devoted roughly 175,000 hours to research and public education for a more peaceful world: thinking, researching, writing, organising, publishing, debating, maintaining websites, corresponding, reaching out, leading a foundation, work in conflict and war zones, professorships, teaching courses and giving public lectures and doing media work. In short, ten hours a day, seven days a week, for half a century. The focus was on international political peace – analysing and trying to stop wars, address underlying conflicts and making alternative peace plans – at the desk and on the ground. Important as that has been and remains, it is only one kind of peace and it is now in a tragic militarist state compared with what it could have been.  Lately, however, I have found myself thinking about a concept from economics as well as everyday...
Photo above: Carl Fredrik Reuterswärd’s Non-Violence outside UN Headquarters in New York. Kirill Levin, CC BY-NC-SA 2. Jan Oberg November 3, 2026 I am happy to be published in Horizons which is produced by the Center for International Relations and Sustainable Development, CIRSD, in Belgrade. My contribution brings out a radical re-thinking of what concepts such as defence, security, deterrence – and peace – may mean if we want to create a more peaceful world. It also summarises a few things I have been working with the last few decades. Please read it here Og her er den på dansk, takket være Johnny Baltzersens lynhurtige oversættelse
UNITE-tillid, DREAM-velstand og andre konstruktive komponenter Normally we publish articles in English here. But this is a translation of a very important TFF document that should reach as many as possible in Denmark since this country’s government has been one of the most hardline in Europe and, up till now at least, has refused to use diplomacy and, instead, spent tremendous sums on arming Ukraine with the express goal of defeating Russia. Thus this – unique – article is in Danish. Vi er Johnny Baltzersen og hans Fælles Sikkerhed – Fælles Fremtid på Substack overmåde taknemmelige for at have oversat og publiceret TFF’s 2025-portfølje for fredsidéer med henblik på Ukraines fremtid. Vi håber den nu kan nå mange flere danskere – som også vil sprede den og skabe debat – nu den danske regerings og folketingspartiernes politik på dette område siden 2022 står nu – forudsigeligt – ved vejs ende....
Read More
AbstractVision_2017_#1_800 (kopia)
A Message from Jan Oberg November 6, 2026 Over the past fifty years, I have devoted roughly 175,000 hours to research and public education for a more peaceful world: thinking, researching, writing, organising, publishing, debating, maintaining websites, corresponding, reaching out, leading a foundation, work in conflict and war zones, professorships, teaching courses and giving public lectures and doing media work. In short, ten hours a day, seven days a week, for half a century. The focus was on international political peace – analysing and trying to stop wars, address underlying conflicts and making alternative peace plans – at the desk and on the ground. Important as that has been and remains, it is only one kind of peace and it is now in a tragic militarist state compared with what it could have been.  Lately, however, I have found myself thinking about a concept from economics as well as everyday...
knotted gun
Photo above: Carl Fredrik Reuterswärd’s Non-Violence outside UN Headquarters in New York. Kirill Levin, CC BY-NC-SA 2. Jan Oberg November 3, 2026 I am happy to be published in Horizons which is produced by the Center for International Relations and Sustainable Development, CIRSD, in Belgrade. My contribution brings out a radical re-thinking of what concepts such as defence, security, deterrence – and peace – may mean if we want to create a more peaceful world. It also summarises a few things I have been working with the last few decades. Please read it here Og her er den på dansk, takket være Johnny Baltzersens lynhurtige oversættelse
TFFPortfolioVign
UNITE-tillid, DREAM-velstand og andre konstruktive komponenter Normally we publish articles in English here. But this is a translation of a very important TFF document that should reach as many as possible in Denmark since this country’s government has been one of the most hardline in Europe and, up till now at least, has refused to use diplomacy and, instead, spent tremendous sums on arming Ukraine with the express goal of defeating Russia. Thus this – unique – article is in Danish. Vi er Johnny Baltzersen og hans Fælles Sikkerhed – Fælles Fremtid på Substack overmåde taknemmelige for at have oversat og publiceret TFF’s 2025-portfølje for fredsidéer med henblik på Ukraines fremtid. Vi håber den nu kan nå mange flere danskere – som også vil sprede den og skabe debat – nu den danske regerings og folketingspartiernes politik på dette område siden 2022 står nu – forudsigeligt – ved vejs ende....
JoGSS-Silent
Jan Oberg TFF director October 28, 2026 Exactly one month has now passed since I published my criticism of the introduction to the special issue on Johan Galtung published by the Journal of Global Security Studies, JoGSS, and of Tor Egil Førland’s chapter about Galtung which serves as a preview to his forthcoming biography of Galtung to be published by PRIO. See the original on The Transnational here and the same article on TFF Substack with many general and critical comments and, in particular, the people who decided to withdraw from the biography project in protest. The special issue itself was extraordinary. It was devoted to the intellectual legacy of one of the founders of peace research and contained a number of strong assessments of his personality, scholarship, intellectual trajectory, and public role. Such assessments are, of course, entirely legitimate. No scholar is beyond criticism, and neither was Johan Galtung....
Screenshot 2026-10-26 115647
An aspect of Iran’s culture and civilisation you’ve probably never heard about. Don’t be surprised if the US and Israel also try to bomb them. Jan ObergTFF director October 26, 2026 Today – under the “USraeli” threat of new “annihilating” bombings – opens the 7th International Conference on Peace and Conflict Resolution at Tehran’s University. As far as I can tell, this is the only permanent, advanced peace research institution in West Asia/the Middle East. Perhaps more countries in that region could be inspired? I mean, how many military “security” institutes and military academies do they have? Many peace research institutes and university departments have been established since the 1950s in the West. They are now all under attack; some have closed down, some have gone mainstream, yet others kept the name but do nothing to research peace and disseminate results or advice; instead, they cooperate with militarism’s platforms such...
Screenshot 2026-10-15 141837
Let’s discuss using AI to create peace – in contrast to boring geopolitics devoid of creative healing and visions. Jan Oberg TFF director October 15, 2026 I asked VEED to create a short video exemplifying how peace is preferable to war, then chose the lady as a template. Simple as that. In less than a minute, it produced this video, which any peace-loving person would appreciate. The only problem is that human intelligence (HI), at least the one that exists among Western decision-makers, isn’t half as moral or smart as AI. I have used AI to dialogue about peace and peace plans, creative conflict resolution and visions of a better future for humankind. It so happens that I am having more stimulating, intelligent, creative and moral discussions with AI than I could possibly have with any EU or NATO leader today. Yes, AI has very problematic and dangerous aspects; used...