Review Zelim Skurbaty’s “As If People Mattered”

johangaltung

AS IF PEOPLES MATTERED
By Zelim Skurbaty
Published by Kluwer Law International
Martinus Nijhoff Publishers
The Hague/Boston/London, 2000, xxvii + 498pp.
The Raoul Wallenberg Institute Human Rights Library Vol. 4

Dr Skurbaty has written a very important book, probably destined to become something of a classic. He draws upon an enormous amount of philosophy, humanities and social science and footnotes everything, including his frequent use of Latin.

He is a learned, not only educated, man, up to a level I have only experienced in academies in the old Soviet Union, leaning on the older Russian tradition now disappearing rapidly, yielding to business administration and computer science there as elsewhere. As a learned man Skurbaty belongs to an endangered species; his is not the kind of knowledge picked up by a voracious reader but knowledge with purpose. He mobilizes his intellectual apparatus to explore well-mined territory occupied by international law.

Then there are the many philosophical and social science excursions, whether read as refresher courses or as initiation, always important. For him the whole legal approach is located in the interphase between philosophy and the “machine” — the legal machinery, he quotes Le Corbusier on the house as a machine for living. The philosophy defines our values, the machine implements them. And Skurbaty’s analysis of how they then proceed to play games is masterly, using the whole machinery for non-implementation rather than implementation.

My first doubt centers on the word “our”. Where is this majestic “we”? I see for my inner eye armies of lawyers, white upper/middle class Western Big Power male from uniervsities serving the state, and those trained by them. I smell class, “ours” for sure, in people taking sleep and toilet so much for granted that they do not even figure as universal human rights. Take an example: the Badinter commission on Yugoslavia, quoted at some length. Imagine they had been courageous and creative enough to acknowledge the Chinese boxes nature of “peoples”, with peoples within peoples within peoples, and not so scared by the word-pair secession-independence that they cannot open for a wide range of types of autonomy. The Croats had an obvious right to self-determination, but so do the Serbsin Krajina and Slavonija (and, problematic for those Serbs, how about Croat minorities inside those territories?) Being French, as Skurbaty indicates, they of course had Basques and Corsicans in mind when they were writing their “opinion” (a correct term, see p. 257). Uti possidetis, the disastrous Damocles sword hanging over the whole self-determination exercise, serves as a protection of status quo, and was used–possibly with the whole Yugoslav disaster as a result. The Badinter commission did a lousy job because they could play that game with impunity.

The book is not easy reading. But then it can be read in at least two ways. Each part, each section and sub-section, is self-contained and conveys enormous, useful information, for instance his “clinical” cases, such as Yugoslavia, Palestine, and above all Chechnya. Or, take footnote 11 on p. 76: the list of 32 peoples nested inside European nation-states – with very violent, or distant premonitions of coming struggles between nationalism for autonomy, sovereignty, even – God forbid -independence. To me they are like the famous seeds under asphalt or water in the crevices of a mountain: come spring and they sprout, come winter and the water freezes. And the asphalt bursts and so does the mountain because of some very simple properties of seeds and water. Well, not always. Smear on layers of asphalt and granite and some flexibility and it helps. What is this force? Skurbaty deals not only with peoples, but also with minorities. For the latter he quotes Asbjoern Eide’s very useful definition pointing to the obvious but often forgotten: minority is an artihmetic entity, it means less than half. Why that concern? Because democracy has a built-in obsession with more than half, called the “will of the people.” If the people is the Sovereign then there have to be limitations on that sovereign power lest it ends in despotic absolutism. Hence human rights protection also in, and for, democracies.

But that is not the end of the story, as Skurbaty’s title, a skilful play on Schumacher’s famous “Economics as if people mattered”, indicates. So, what constitutes a “people”? Well, they are different from people around them. And they seem to have one simple characteristic in common that I wish Skurbaty had highlighted more: they want at least their proximate rulers to be of their own kind; they detest rule by other peoples. Some of them may say that to be ruled by their kind at local or district level is enough and claim autonomy, others may say the state level is needed and claim independence, still others, like Americans, want nobody in any form on top of them, not the UN for instance, and claim universal sovereignty, highly compatible with building a universal empire (to want nobody on top can also be a cloak for wanting to be on top of others.)

Let us face it: given the choice, many people would prefer being ruled by their own dictator to being ruled democratically by a majority not of their own kind. To use a well-known quote: he may be a son-of-a-bitch but he is our son-of-a-bitch. Human right and democracy will be seen as a game, one more majority way of legitimizing the state as a prison of peoples. But most seem to want both: a democracy, of, for and by their own demos. And that may spell secession, unless the ruling majority has sufficient skill to be flexible and work out some scheme for (con)federation, territorial or–much more promising–non- territorial. Very often not even that is needed. Even individual human rights may do: give them the right to talk their own language and practice their own religion in private and public space, and the quest may start withering away. Go one step further, give them group rights, e.g., to run their own schools in their own idiom with full recognition and that may be a successful conflict transformation.

For those believing in humanism and humanist ethics rather than theism and theocratic ethics the quest for recognition is satisfied when major rites- naming, confirmation, wedding, burial–are run by themselves, their way. Homosexuals are in the early stages of that struggle. But what happens if humanists, gays and lesbians want to be governed by their own kind, and only their own kind?

That quest for religious autonomy was exactly the pillar on which the USA was founded. But, and Skurbaty might have given more attention to that, the problem is not so much that the difficulty defining a people when they are also playing games (will this definition destabilize my country?) as the fact that the criteria are changing. The world may become polyglot and ecumenical. But that is not the end of the story. New criteria of people-ness, like sexual orientation, may come up any time.

One criterion plays a surprisingly minor role in Skurbaty’s dense, rich volume: territorial attachment (the index has few references to territory). With tourism being the biggest world industry, and migration a major fact of life, one may argue that people become poly-spatial, ecu-territorial. This may be true, but we are not there yet. There is asynchrony in the world. Globalized upper/middle class Big Power males, poly-glot, secularized and poly-jet, may project their sense of non- ttachment to such “tribal” characteristics as idiom, faith and territorial attachment to some plains or hills on the rest of humanity, and proclaim some new universal principle. But to those others, billions of them, they look like a power-greedy ayer of global foam floating on top of the world, attached to nothing but their own egocentric greed, suffering from advanced anomie (no compelling values) and atomie (no social tissue).

And that is where my second objection enters: Skurbaty’s use of “individuation”. He mentions e pluribus unum and collective-in-the individual, indicative of sensitivity to the I-we dialectic. But there are cultures leaning more to the I side and cultures leaning more to the we-side. Skurbaty’s individuation favors I-cultures and sounds like a plea for individuals to escape from collective strait-jackets. The problem is whether this is not also a plea for anomie (culture-lessness) and atomie (structure-lessness) in the present reality of postmodernism, favoring the egocentric cost-benefit amoral code of economism considerably more than the Scripture Skurbaty appeals to. Skurbaty might have benefitted from the literature on Cambodia, a Buddhist we-culture exposed to a Western I- culture in the form of Western democracy and individualized human rights that in the longer run may prove as lethal as the killing fields of US bombing and the Khmer Rouge. I sense culture-blindness behind “individuation”, added to the structure-blindness of “our” mentioned above.

But I leave this aside. Skurbaty’s book remains a tour de force. A gold mine of nuggets to be polished for years to come. Whoever reads the book will be grateful that the book exists.

Related Posts

LONDON – So far so good, at least on the wider level. While internally Iraq seems on the edge of chaos, the much heralded clash of civilizations between the Muslim and Judaeo-Christian worlds has yet to become apparent. We have anger and despair aplenty in the Arab and Muslim worlds. But very little rushing to the standard and there was no great pilgrimage of warriors to join the fight, as happened when the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan twenty years ago, and then, having driven the Red Army out, were left to ferment in that mountainous redoubt. With the armaments supplied by the CIA the mujahidin were transformed into Al Qaeda that became, for a relatively brief moment as these things go, ‘the greatest threat to the homeland that America has ever known.’ Nevertheless a ‘Cold War’ between much of the Muslim world and the West is certainly in full swing. Winston...
The Challenge of Nuclear Weaponsin the Twenty-first CenturyA Path Forward The peoples and governments of the world face an urgent challenge relating to weaponry of mass destruction and particularly to nuclear weaponry.  At the crossroads of technology, terrorism, geopolitical ambition, and policies of preemption are new and potent dangers for humanity. Despite ending the nuclear standoff of the Cold War era, nuclear weaponry is again menacing the peoples of the world with catastrophic possibilities.  We recognize the need for any government to pursue its security interests in accordance with international law; and further, we recognize that distinctive threats to these interests now exist as a result of an active international terrorist network having declared war on the United States and its allies. Nonetheless, we reject the assessment of the current US administration that upgrading a reliance on nuclear weapons is in any sense justified as a response. We find it...
By Karin Wegestal MP, the Social Democratic Partyon behalf of the Swedish Committee for Solidarity with the Yugoslav People During the last decade, the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia has received more than 500,000 refugees from Croatia and Bosnia, and another 300,000 internally displaced persons, mainly from the province Kosovo and Metohia. For a country with about ten million inhabitants, such an influx of homeless people is obviously a very heavy burden – even under peaceful conditions. But in addition to that, the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia has been the subject to sanctions from the western powers for close to ten years and its infrastructure was badly hurt through Nato’s intense bombardment during 78 days in 1999. The result of all this is that Yugoslavia, once the most developed industrial country in Eastern Europe, is today the poorest country in Europe. In Serbia excluding Kosovo, with about ten million inhabitants and...

Recent Articles

A Message from Jan Oberg November 6, 2026 Over the past fifty years, I have devoted roughly 175,000 hours to research and public education for a more peaceful world: thinking, researching, writing, organising, publishing, debating, maintaining websites, corresponding, reaching out, leading a foundation, work in conflict and war zones, professorships, teaching courses and giving public lectures and doing media work. In short, ten hours a day, seven days a week, for half a century. The focus was on international political peace – analysing and trying to stop wars, address underlying conflicts and making alternative peace plans – at the desk and on the ground. Important as that has been and remains, it is only one kind of peace and it is now in a tragic militarist state compared with what it could have been.  Lately, however, I have found myself thinking about a concept from economics as well as everyday...
Photo above: Carl Fredrik Reuterswärd’s Non-Violence outside UN Headquarters in New York. Kirill Levin, CC BY-NC-SA 2. Jan Oberg November 3, 2026 I am happy to be published in Horizons which is produced by the Center for International Relations and Sustainable Development, CIRSD, in Belgrade. My contribution brings out a radical re-thinking of what concepts such as defence, security, deterrence – and peace – may mean if we want to create a more peaceful world. It also summarises a few things I have been working with the last few decades. Please read it here Og her er den på dansk, takket være Johnny Baltzersens lynhurtige oversættelse
UNITE-tillid, DREAM-velstand og andre konstruktive komponenter Normally we publish articles in English here. But this is a translation of a very important TFF document that should reach as many as possible in Denmark since this country’s government has been one of the most hardline in Europe and, up till now at least, has refused to use diplomacy and, instead, spent tremendous sums on arming Ukraine with the express goal of defeating Russia. Thus this – unique – article is in Danish. Vi er Johnny Baltzersen og hans Fælles Sikkerhed – Fælles Fremtid på Substack overmåde taknemmelige for at have oversat og publiceret TFF’s 2025-portfølje for fredsidéer med henblik på Ukraines fremtid. Vi håber den nu kan nå mange flere danskere – som også vil sprede den og skabe debat – nu den danske regerings og folketingspartiernes politik på dette område siden 2022 står nu – forudsigeligt – ved vejs ende....

TFF on Substack

Discover and subscribe to more peace materials on TFF Substack

Most Popular

A Message from Jan Oberg November 6, 2026 Over the past fifty years, I have devoted roughly 175,000 hours to research and public education for a more peaceful world: thinking, researching, writing, organising, publishing, debating, maintaining websites, corresponding, reaching out, leading a foundation, work in conflict and war zones, professorships, teaching courses and giving public lectures and doing media work. In short, ten hours a day, seven days a week, for half a century. The focus was on international political peace – analysing and trying to stop wars, address underlying conflicts and making alternative peace plans – at the desk and on the ground. Important as that has been and remains, it is only one kind of peace and it is now in a tragic militarist state compared with what it could have been.  Lately, however, I have found myself thinking about a concept from economics as well as everyday...
Photo above: Carl Fredrik Reuterswärd’s Non-Violence outside UN Headquarters in New York. Kirill Levin, CC BY-NC-SA 2. Jan Oberg November 3, 2026 I am happy to be published in Horizons which is produced by the Center for International Relations and Sustainable Development, CIRSD, in Belgrade. My contribution brings out a radical re-thinking of what concepts such as defence, security, deterrence – and peace – may mean if we want to create a more peaceful world. It also summarises a few things I have been working with the last few decades. Please read it here Og her er den på dansk, takket være Johnny Baltzersens lynhurtige oversættelse
UNITE-tillid, DREAM-velstand og andre konstruktive komponenter Normally we publish articles in English here. But this is a translation of a very important TFF document that should reach as many as possible in Denmark since this country’s government has been one of the most hardline in Europe and, up till now at least, has refused to use diplomacy and, instead, spent tremendous sums on arming Ukraine with the express goal of defeating Russia. Thus this – unique – article is in Danish. Vi er Johnny Baltzersen og hans Fælles Sikkerhed – Fælles Fremtid på Substack overmåde taknemmelige for at have oversat og publiceret TFF’s 2025-portfølje for fredsidéer med henblik på Ukraines fremtid. Vi håber den nu kan nå mange flere danskere – som også vil sprede den og skabe debat – nu den danske regerings og folketingspartiernes politik på dette område siden 2022 står nu – forudsigeligt – ved vejs ende....
Read More
AbstractVision_2017_#1_800 (kopia)
A Message from Jan Oberg November 6, 2026 Over the past fifty years, I have devoted roughly 175,000 hours to research and public education for a more peaceful world: thinking, researching, writing, organising, publishing, debating, maintaining websites, corresponding, reaching out, leading a foundation, work in conflict and war zones, professorships, teaching courses and giving public lectures and doing media work. In short, ten hours a day, seven days a week, for half a century. The focus was on international political peace – analysing and trying to stop wars, address underlying conflicts and making alternative peace plans – at the desk and on the ground. Important as that has been and remains, it is only one kind of peace and it is now in a tragic militarist state compared with what it could have been.  Lately, however, I have found myself thinking about a concept from economics as well as everyday...
knotted gun
Photo above: Carl Fredrik Reuterswärd’s Non-Violence outside UN Headquarters in New York. Kirill Levin, CC BY-NC-SA 2. Jan Oberg November 3, 2026 I am happy to be published in Horizons which is produced by the Center for International Relations and Sustainable Development, CIRSD, in Belgrade. My contribution brings out a radical re-thinking of what concepts such as defence, security, deterrence – and peace – may mean if we want to create a more peaceful world. It also summarises a few things I have been working with the last few decades. Please read it here Og her er den på dansk, takket være Johnny Baltzersens lynhurtige oversættelse
TFFPortfolioVign
UNITE-tillid, DREAM-velstand og andre konstruktive komponenter Normally we publish articles in English here. But this is a translation of a very important TFF document that should reach as many as possible in Denmark since this country’s government has been one of the most hardline in Europe and, up till now at least, has refused to use diplomacy and, instead, spent tremendous sums on arming Ukraine with the express goal of defeating Russia. Thus this – unique – article is in Danish. Vi er Johnny Baltzersen og hans Fælles Sikkerhed – Fælles Fremtid på Substack overmåde taknemmelige for at have oversat og publiceret TFF’s 2025-portfølje for fredsidéer med henblik på Ukraines fremtid. Vi håber den nu kan nå mange flere danskere – som også vil sprede den og skabe debat – nu den danske regerings og folketingspartiernes politik på dette område siden 2022 står nu – forudsigeligt – ved vejs ende....
JoGSS-Silent
Jan Oberg TFF director October 28, 2026 Exactly one month has now passed since I published my criticism of the introduction to the special issue on Johan Galtung published by the Journal of Global Security Studies, JoGSS, and of Tor Egil Førland’s chapter about Galtung which serves as a preview to his forthcoming biography of Galtung to be published by PRIO. See the original on The Transnational here and the same article on TFF Substack with many general and critical comments and, in particular, the people who decided to withdraw from the biography project in protest. The special issue itself was extraordinary. It was devoted to the intellectual legacy of one of the founders of peace research and contained a number of strong assessments of his personality, scholarship, intellectual trajectory, and public role. Such assessments are, of course, entirely legitimate. No scholar is beyond criticism, and neither was Johan Galtung....
Screenshot 2026-10-26 115647
An aspect of Iran’s culture and civilisation you’ve probably never heard about. Don’t be surprised if the US and Israel also try to bomb them. Jan ObergTFF director October 26, 2026 Today – under the “USraeli” threat of new “annihilating” bombings – opens the 7th International Conference on Peace and Conflict Resolution at Tehran’s University. As far as I can tell, this is the only permanent, advanced peace research institution in West Asia/the Middle East. Perhaps more countries in that region could be inspired? I mean, how many military “security” institutes and military academies do they have? Many peace research institutes and university departments have been established since the 1950s in the West. They are now all under attack; some have closed down, some have gone mainstream, yet others kept the name but do nothing to research peace and disseminate results or advice; instead, they cooperate with militarism’s platforms such...
Screenshot 2026-10-15 141837
Let’s discuss using AI to create peace – in contrast to boring geopolitics devoid of creative healing and visions. Jan Oberg TFF director October 15, 2026 I asked VEED to create a short video exemplifying how peace is preferable to war, then chose the lady as a template. Simple as that. In less than a minute, it produced this video, which any peace-loving person would appreciate. The only problem is that human intelligence (HI), at least the one that exists among Western decision-makers, isn’t half as moral or smart as AI. I have used AI to dialogue about peace and peace plans, creative conflict resolution and visions of a better future for humankind. It so happens that I am having more stimulating, intelligent, creative and moral discussions with AI than I could possibly have with any EU or NATO leader today. Yes, AI has very problematic and dangerous aspects; used...